Nature and necessity guy robinson determinism is a spectre that has haunted our scientificallyoriented culture from the beginning. Voltaire once swam the atlantic for example is surely implausible indeed, there is a clear sense in which it is impossible. Among recent contributions to the problem of interpreting modality is the nature of necessity, which presents alvin plantingas most comprehensive attempt to develop a unified treatment of necessity. You can publish your own pdf file online for free in a few minutes. The metaphysics of modality university of kentucky. Alvin plantinga hand, it is narrower than that of causal or natural necessity. Plantinga and the problem of evil iowa state university. Obrien professor of philosophy at the university of notre dame.
A longawaited major statement by preeminent analytic philosopher alvin plantinga, where the conflict really lies illuminates one of our societys biggest debates the conflict between science and religion. During this period plantingas work centers on a defense of the rationality of religious belief in the book god and other minds, general metaphysics and philosophy of religion in the nature of necessity, and the longstanding conundrum of the existence of evil in a world where god is omnipotent in the nature of. Plantinga does a great job with his version of the ontological argument. His modal ontological argument for foundational religious necessity is seen as an almost. The argument is developed by means of the notion of possible. Voltaire once swam the atlantic for example is surely implausible indeed, there is a. Ix god, evil, and the metaphysics of freedom abstract. The author develops the notion of possible worlds, discusses the question of transwrold identity and the nature of individuals, and considers the problem of. Alvin plantinga, born in 1932, is a philosopher and has been a professor at both calvin university and the university of notre dame. Here, plantinga attempted to use the philosophical concept of possible worlds. T his is a collection of philosophical papers by alvin plantinga. In the nature of necessity, the argument is presented in a technical.
On the one hand, it means the set of all things which are natural, or subject to the normal working of the laws of nature. Plantinga is widely known for his work in philosophy of religion, epistemology, metaphysics and christian apologetics. V, 12, the necessity of natures 22 actualist realism ii plantinga 1974, from the nature of necessity ch. Has plantinga buried mackies logical argument from evil. The distinction between necessary and contingent truth is as easy to. Alvin plantinga, the nature of necessity philpapers. On the other hand, it means the essential properties and causes of individual things. In what follows, i shall set out, to begin with, a statement of the main line of his argument 3. Oct 12, 2009 the nature of necessity by alvin plantinga is quite the philosophy book. Alvin plantinga addresses the classic ontological argument in two books published in 1 974. Alvin plantinga 1 preliminary distinctions and remarks a.
Plantingas the nature of necessity 1974 contains a largely neglected argument for the claim that the proposition god is omnipotent, omniscient, and wholly good is logically consistent with the vast amount and variety of evil the universe actually contains not to be confused with plantingas famous free will defense, which seeks to show that this same proposition is. Plantingas theory is his scheme for the reduction of. In the first chapter i try to locate and fix the idea in questionthe idea of broadly logical necessityand to distinguish it from. This book, one of the first fulllength studies of the modalities to emerge from the debate to which saul kripke, david lewis, ruth marcus and others have. Berkeley himself frowns upon at least certain uses of the term occasion because they presuppose a belief in matter. Plantinga apparently articulated his arguments for the truth of counterfactuals without any knowledge of molinism. The nature of necessity clarendon library of logic and philosophy alvin plantinga. I argue that each object has many essences sometimes referred to as hacceities or natures. Jan 01, 1974 in nature of necessity, plantinga explains the use of possible worlds philosophy. The nature of necessity by alvin plantinga, 1974 online. In perfect being theology, god is defined as a maximally great being which means that god possesses all greatmaking, properties such as love, knowledge, and power, and possesses each in a maximal way. Gods presence within henrys phenomenology of life mdpi. Articles 2016 law, cause, and occasionalism, in reason and faith.
In this, the aquinas lecture for 1980, alvin plantinga proposes p. How to understand the meaning and significance of nature has been a consistent theme. Plantinga develops his argument by means of the notion of possible worlds and ranges over such key problems as the nature of essence, transworld identity, negative existential propositions, and the existence of unactual objects in other possible worlds. Oct 18, 2012 plantingas the nature of necessity 1974 contains a largely neglected argument for the claim that the proposition god is omnipotent, omniscient, and wholly good is logically consistent with the vast amount and variety of evil the universe actually contains not to be confused with plantingas famous free will defense, which seeks to show that this same proposition is. Plantingas defence of the free will defence in chapter nine. In each of these books, he analyzes the classical ontological argument and ev entually formulates his own contemporary modal version. Finally, i shall set out a criticism of plantingas. The nature of necessity and god, f reedom, and evil. I happen to think that it is literally a spectre, a trick of the vision, an appearance with an internal cause only, and that it is no more than the ghost of our own conceptual determinations projected.
As the son of a philosophy and psychology professor, plantinga evidenced a knack for and interest in philosophy early on. For example, one maximal world segment of the actual world includes everything up to george w. Under the heading of natural theology, plantinga briefly rehashes the treatment of. An introduction to the thought of alvin plantinga crossway. Among recent contributions to the problem of interpreting modality is the nature of necessity, which presents alvin plantinga s most comprehensive attempt to develop a unified treatment of necessity. Modal logic is a course about the logic of necessity and possibility. Necessity circumscribed as the distinction between necessary and contingent truth is easy to recognize as it is difficult to explain to the sceptics satisfaction. In particular i will use the lecture given by plantinga on this topic plantinga 1980. Following alvin plantinga, i take a state of affairs s to be maximal just in case for any state of affairs s, s either includes s or precludes s 6. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders.
Nature has two interrelated meanings in philosophy. The nature of necessity by alvin plantinga is quite the philosophy book. Since alvin plantingas god and other minds 1967, the nature of necessity and god, freedom, and. An individual user may print out a pdf of a single chapter of a monograph in oso for personal use. The nature of necessity clarendon library of logic. For much of the book i felt like i was up against a level 97 boss, and im only at level 70. The nature of necessity alvin plantinga download bok. In the nature of necessity 1974a and god, freedom and evil 1974b plantinga argues, also famously, that mackies argument isnt sound.
A humean objection to plantingas quantitative free will defense. Plantingas treatments of the problem of evil and the ontological argument, his examination. What is plantingas free will defense, and how does it address the problem of evil. Here, plantinga attempted to use the philosophical concept of possible worlds to show the necessary nature of gods existence. Plantinga developed his modal version of the ontological argument for the existence of god in his two controversial books, the nature of necessity 1974. The problem of evil is the objection to theism that holds that the conjunction of the propositions, god is omnipotent. In the first three chapters, i clarify and defend the distinction between. I then elaborate on the nature of essences and examine the relationship between essences and proper names. Philosophical foundations for a christian worldview james porter moreland. He is the author of numerous books including god and other minds, the nature of necessity, and a trilogy of books on epistemology, culminating in warranted christian belief.
See three dialogues between hylas and philonous, edited by robert m. Alvin plantinga is regarded as one of the foremost religious philosophers of the contemporary era. What is plantingas free will defense, and how does it. This is still alvin plantingas most impressive book to date. Plantinga, alvin professor of philosophy, university of notre dame. Alvin carl plantinga born 1932 is an american analytic philosopher who works primarily in the fields of philosophy of religion, epistemology particularly on issues involving epistemic justification, and logic from 1963 to 1982, plantinga taught at calvin university before accepting an appointment as the john a.
The necessity of natures the necessity of natures chapter. The author develops the notion of possible worlds, discusses the question of transwrold identity and the. The work is organized around the problem of providing. A property e is an essence of object x if and only if e is essential to x and in every possible world everything distinct from x has the complement of e essentially. Eighteenth century intellectuals as distinguished from dol phins simply lacked the physical equipment for this kind of feat. Alvin plantinga, in the ninth chapter ofthe nature of necessity, sets out a defence of the free will defence fwd 2. He is credited with formulating the most robust and wellrespected response to the logical problem of evil. He also applies his logical theories to the elucidation. The nature of necessity alvin plantinga oxford university press. I shall, then, set out a number of minor criticisms of the ninth chapter. A philosophical masterpiece that excels in modal logic. Print isbn, doi alvin plantingas recent book 1 might better be titled the.
Plantinga examines where this conflict is said to existlooking at areas such as evolution, divine action in the world, and the scientific study of religionand he considers claims by. The nature of necessity 9780198244141 by alvin plantinga. A humean objection to plantingas quantitative free will. Chapter 9 is the first of two chapters that apply the findings of the previous eight chapters of the nature of necessity to some traditional problems in natural theology. Raised in the christian reformed church, he has theological roots in the dutch reformed tradition.
In nature of necessity, plantinga explains the use of possible worlds philosophy. Jul 06, 2019 alvin plantinga the nature of necessity pdf posted on july 6, 2019 by admin this book, one of the first fulllength studies of the modalities to emerge from the debate to which saul kripke, david lewis, ruth marcus, and. Apr 25, 2017 alvin plantinga was born in ann arbor, michigan. The nature of necessity, together with a series of subsequent articles, constitutes what is perhaps the most sophisticated theory of possible worlds yet to be. It is one of the first fulllength studies of the modalities to emerge from the debate to which saul kripke, david lewis, ruth marcus and others have contributed. Themes from richard swinburne, bergmann and brower, eds. Phil6312 introduction to modal logic new orleans baptist. Some of plantinga s most influential works include god and other minds 1967, the nature of necessity 1974, and a trilogy of books on epistemology, culminating in warranted christian belief 2000 that was simplified in knowledge and christian belief 2016. Plantinga is concerned about the relation of abstract objects and necessary features of. I will summarize what plantinga has to say, examine his answer to this question and provide one of my own based on the themes of this thesis. Maslow iiiiuin compass penguin 800ks published by the penguin group penguin group usa inc.
739 1462 945 1088 877 243 689 828 1064 217 877 970 1472 269 1278 1001 1171 181 16 612 374 1208 1292 17 524 896 354 1438 133 120 528 1364 1313 1367 1368 565 1495 495 467 1018 982 1345 727 535 867 1202 789 1261 1410 593 1052